JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← Back to document

Compare editions

65 lines added, 67 removed

- ARC By-Law
-
- ## A BY-LAW OF THE DUKE STUDENT GOVERNMENT
+ RGAC By-Law Mission The student-run Residential House Assessment (RGA) process seeks to promote healthy interactions between members of Selective Houses (SHs) and the broader residential community.
- Establishing the Selective Living Group Approval and Removal Committee (ARC)
+ 1. Responsibilities of the Residential House Assessment Committee (RGAC)
- 1. TITLE I. OVERVIEW Section I. ARC Description
+ 1. The RGAC shall carry out the annual RGA process.
- 1. The Selective Living Group Approval and Removal Committee (henceforth referred to as the “ARC”) shall consist of a joint student/administrative advisory board tasked with considering petitions from students wishing to create a selective living group and/or extend or seek other privileges for an existing group. ARC has the ability to remove groups as well.
+ 2. The RGAC shall host a mandatory information session for all SH liaisons at the beginning of each semester.
- Section II. Purview and Powers
+ 3. The RGAC Chair and Vice Chair shall be available to answer SH liaisons’ questions at any point during the process.
- 1. The ARC shall have the ability to approve the creation of a new selective living group, and the sanctioning of housing for that group
+ 4. The RGAC shall solicit feedback regarding the RGA process from students and administrators following each annual assessment.
- 2. The ARC shall have the ability to sanction a current living group, including measures such as removing a current living group’s housing and/or placing a group on probation.
+ 2. The Composition of the Residential House Assessment Committee
- 3. The ARC shall have the ability to make changes to a group’s space, privileges, and other housing circumstances
+ 1. 1 Committee Chair
- 4. HDRL shall not approve new selective living groups, cannot sanction a current group, and cannot make a change to a group’s space, privileges, and other housing circumstances without the recommendation and approval of the ARC Section III. Committee Operation
+ 1. i. To be selected by the Residential Life committee of Duke Student Government (DSG). The Chair may not be affiliated with or be a friend of house of any house being evaluated under the RGA process. After completing a one-year term, the Chair may reapply to serve another term. If the Chair does not serve another term, that student will serve as a non-voting advisor to the RGA committee until they graduate.
- 1. The ARC shall operate independently of DSG and the DSG Residential Life and Dining Committee, although the Residential Life and Dining committee may issue non-binding recommendations (by majority vote) to the ARC pertaining to upcoming decisions to be made by the ARC
+ 2. ii. The Chair need not be a member of Duke Student Government
- 2. The ARC shall be convened at the discretion of Housing, Dining, and Residence Life (HDRL) in consultation with the DSG Vice President for Residential Life and Dining (RLD)
+ 2. 1 Vice Chair
- 1. Typically, the ARC shall meet at the end of each academic year prior to Room Picks
+ 1. i. To be selected by the Residential Life committee. The Vice Chair may not be affiliated with or be a friend of house of any house being evaluated under the RGA process.
- 2. The ARC shall first resolve any outstanding petitions in a first meeting.
+ 2. ii. The Vice Chair need not be a member of Duke Student Government.
- 3. The ARC shall then address any new petitions resulting from the impact of the first meeting. These petitions may include, but are not limited to, requests for space from groups whose space was affected by the first ARC meeting’s decisions.
+ 3. 2 Unaffiliated Representatives
- 4. The ARC shall have the ability to request written or verbal testimony pertaining to items under its deliberation from affected parties.
+ 1. i. To be selected by the Residential Life committee. Unaffiliated representatives may not be affiliated with or be a friend of house of any house being evaluated under the RGA process.
- 5. The ARC shall work directly with the DSG Residential Life and Dining committee, or those recommended by the DSG Residential Life and Dining committee, in order to determine and select appropriate housing for new residential groups.
+ 2. ii. The Unaffiliated representatives need not be a member of Duke Student Government.
- 6. Each voting member of the ARC shall be assigned equal voting power of one vote.
+ 4. 1 Interfraternity Council (IFC) Representatives
- 7. The ARC shall be co-chaired by the DSG Vice President of RLD, along with the Associate Dean of Residential Life, and be composed of the following voting membership:
+ 1. i. To be selected by IFC leadership.
- 1. 1. Administrative:
+ 5. 1 Selective House Council SHC Representatives
- 1. i. The Executive Director of Residential Life
+ 1. i. To be selected by SHC leadership.
- 2. ii. The Residential Dean for West Campus,
+ 6. 1 Panhellenic Representatives
- 3. iii. The Residential Dean for Central Campus,
+ 1. i. To be selected by PanHel leadership.
- 4. iv. The Dean of Undergraduate Education
+ 7. 1 Multicultural Liaison
- 5. v. The Vice President for Student Affairs, and
+ 1. i. One liaison to be selected from the DSG Cabinet
- 6. vi. 2 faculty members selected by the ARC Chairs
+ 8. Staff Advisor
- 7. 2. Student:
+ 1. i. A Staff Advisor may be appointed by HDRL to facilitate communication between selective houses and the RGA committee and the administration.
- 1. i. The VP for Residential Life and Dining
+ 2. ii. The Staff Advisor will provide the benefit of institutional memory and help guide the decisions of the RGA committee.
- 1. 1. If the VP for Residential Life and Dining is a member of a selective living group, then the DSG RLD committee shall choose another member from the RLD committee
+ 3. iii. The Staff Advisor will not have direct authority to overrule the decisions of the RGAC Chair and Vice Chair.
- 2. 2. ii. One representative of the IFC, to be selected by the IFC
+ 9. Any selective house that feels that they are not properly represented in the above committee breakdown structure may send a request to the Vice President of Residential Life for additional representation. The VP of Residential Life shall present the request to the student government and the student government may add representation as it sees fit.
- 3. 3. iii. One representative of the SHC, to be selected by the SHC
+ Any member of the RGAC who neglects their duties or otherwise fails to meet the standards expected may be removed at the discretion of the Chair, Vice Chair, and the RGAC advisor. The responsibility to replace the member will fall to the respective organization which selected the removed representative (DSG, IFC, PanHel, SHC, etc.)
- 4. 4. One multicultural representative appointed from the DSG cabinet
+ 1. Scoring and Evaluation
- 5. 5. One representative from the Panhellenic council, to be selected by the Panhellenic Council
+ 1. Overview of the Process
- 6. 6. iv. ARC can add representatives from umbrella selective group governance bodies at their discretion with the approval the DSG senate.
+ The RGAC shall evaluate Selective Houses annually based on their performance over the course of the previous year in the categories outlined in the accompanying rubric. The RGAC shall not evaluate administratively run housing options such as the Baldwin Scholars, Wellness, and others.
- 7. 7. v
+ 1. i. Timeline: The RGA Chair and Vice Chair, in consultation with the RGA Advisor, will publish an evaluation timetable with all deadlines consistent for all houses. The timetable must be published by October 1 of each year and conform to the requirements outlined in this document and all other relevant materials approved by the Residential Life Committee. The RGA Chair and Co-Chair may petition the Duke Student Government to approve a modification of the scoring timetable outlined in this document.
- 1. vi. Six at-large residentially independent and students to be selected by members of the DSG RLD committee
+ 2. ii. House Liaison: Each house being evaluated will appoint one member to serve as liaison to the RGAC. This liaison will serve as the primary point of contact between the RGAC and the liaison’s respective House, and will assist their house in the preparation and presentation of all materials related to RGAC. The Liaison will explain the process to house members and communicate any questions or concerns on behalf of the house members or the RGAC Chair and Vice Chair. The RGAC Chair and Vice Chair may directly contact house leaders as they deem appropriate, but will respect the primary liaison as the official representative of the house.
- 1. Note: “Residentially independent” shall be defined as an individual who does not live in a selective section, nor is a member of an organization that has a selective section
+ 3. iii. Written Plan Each house being evaluated will be required to submit a written plan, in the appropriate format, demonstrating how the house adhered to the RGAC assessment criteria. The RGAC shall evaluate the written plans under the procedure outlined in this document. The RGA Scoring Rubric included in this document will serve as the basis for evaluation. The RGAC may not amend or deviate in any way from the rubric. In the case of any perceived conflict between this bylaw, the rubric, the RGA handbook, and any other materials approved by DSG, the content of the rubric will not be altered or reinterpreted.
- 2. Note: Individuals within DSG and the DSG RLD committee are eligible to apply, provided they meet the above qualification
+ 4. iv. House Presentations: During If a problem arises during the evaluation process that the RGAC Chair believes could be resolved, or requires, a presentation from a house they are at liberty to call for such a presentation as part of the evaluation process. These presentations will consist of a brief self-assessment in front of the RGAC, including a question-and-answer session with members of the RGAC.
- 3. Other Voting Members:
+ 5. Damage and Excessive Cleaning
- 1. 1. i. The Assistant Dean of Fraternity & Sorority Life shall be seated as a voting member in deliberations concerning a group affiliated with the Office of Fraternity & Sorority Life.
+ 1. i. The RGAC shall convene prior to the assessment and presentation period to assess house damages, provided by HDRL, and assign each damage a classification of “egregious,” “major,” or “minor”.
- 2. 2. ii. The advisor to Selective House council shall be seated as a voting member in deliberations concerning a group affiliated with the Selective House Council.
+ 1. The committee will decide which category each damage will fall into by a simple majority vote.
- 4. Permanent non-voting, ex-officio members:
+ 2. ii. The RGAC will also review the excessive cleaning charges, provided by HDRL.
- 1. 1. i. Representative(s) of the Office of Student Conduct,
+ 3. iii. The following information will be provided to houses at least 72 hours in advance of their assigned presentation timeslot:
- 2. 2. ii. Representative(s) of the Office of Housing Accommodations
+ 1. A review of the in-house damage sustained during evaluation timeframe with the severity classification of each damage incident.
- 3. 3. iii. Representative(s) of the Office of Fraternity and Sorority Life
+ 2. A comprehensive list of all charges billed to the house during the assessment period
- 4. 4. iv. Resident Coordinators (RCs) with oversight of group(s) being discussed
+ 3. iv. In the instance where an individual house member takes personal responsibility for a damage, the severity of said damage count half towards their house’s RGA section damages evaluation.
- 2. Conflicts of Interest:
+ 4. v. Houses may appeal damage and cleaning charges in writing to the RGAC, so long as the appeal is filed more than 24 hours prior to a house’s assigned presentation timeslot. The RGA Chair and Vice Chair will determine the appropriate format and ground for appeals and will communicate this format to each selective house. Appeals in person and appeals submitted after this deadline will not be considered.
- 1. 1. The IFC and the SHC shall each select one alternate representative to the ARC. The alternate representative shall serve during any deliberation in which the primary representative is deemed by the ARC or the IFC or SHC, respectively, to be unable to deliberate objectively due to a conflict of interest. Conflicts of interest include, but are not limited to, membership in a group being considered by the ARC. A group being considered by the ARC may petition the Co-Chairs of the ARC to replace the IFC or SHC representative with the respective substitute during deliberations.
+ 2. RGAC Scoring Practices
- E. The ARC may require written testimony and/or presentations from individuals and groups.
+ 1. i. Each member of the RGAC shall independently pre-score all Selective House written plans prior to group presentations and submit these scores to the RGAC Chair and Vice Chair.
- Section IV. Selection Criteria for New SLGs
+ 2. ii. After a group has presented its self-assessment, evaluators may adjust their scores, but only in response to clarifications and new, material information learned during the presentation. It is expected that the written plan will serve as the primary basis for an evaluator’s score.
- 1. New Groups must provide compelling proof in the ARC presentation and supporting materials that they will meet the following criteria:
+ 3. iii. Following group presentations, the RGAC Chair and Vice Chair will lead the committee in a “conference” session to discuss the performance an scoring of each house and to address any significant differences between individual evaluator’s scores. The RGAC Chair and Vice Chair will provide an opportunity for each evaluator to revise their initial scores. The committee will respect an evaluator’s right to independently score all houses.
- 1. The new group must enhance the experience of its members and positively impact students not affiliated with the group.
+ 4. iv. The RGAC Advisor, Chair, and Vice Chair will calculate average scores for the Community Interaction subsection of each rubric using the same method of dropping the highest and lowest individual scores for that section.
- 2. The new group must demonstrate that it will benefit from and fully utilize its residential space.
+ 3. Release of Final Scores The committee will release RGA scores within one week of the completion of the annual evaluation process.
- Section V. Group Probation
+ The RGAC will consider its deliberations strictly confidential, and will release only:
- 1. The ARC is authorized to place a group on probation at any time.
+ 1. i. Total scores for each house, prepared as outlined in this document.
- 2. This process shall be the primary means of evaluating group stature and conduct.
+ 2. ii. A copy of the Section Management portion of the rubric completed by the RGAC for each house under the guidelines in this document
- 1. Groups that are found deficient of the RGA standard may be placed on probation.
+ 3. Appeal Process Following the release of the RGA scores, all houses will have 24 hours to submit an appeal request in writing to the RGAC Chair, Vice Chair and the DSG vice president of Residential life. Appeals will contain the objections of the group to their RGA score. Appeals will result in a convening of the RGAC committee for a brief presentation by the house, followed by a question-and-answer session with members of the RGAC. The RGAC will have 48 hours from the end of this presentation to change the house in question’s RGA score.
- 2. Once a group is placed on probation, they shall be provided with a written report for why this probation was warranted, and they shall be provided with a series of recommendations for actions that will improve their standing
+ 4. Amendment Process
- 3. A group’s status shall be reviewed the following year as part of the ordinary residential assessment process.
+ 1. The RGA process as outlined in this document will be re-visited, and amended if necessary, by DSG no less than every three years
- 4. Groups may be placed on probation for a second consecutive year. Groups placed on probation for two consecutive years shall either have their probationary status revoked at the end of the second year, or shall have their housing revoked
+ 2. The RGAC process, which is attached, shall be re-evaluated in three years. At this time, the process shall be updated to better reflect the complexities of Duke Houses. Specifically, a class breakdown requirement consisting of 50% sophomores, 30% juniors, and 20% sophomores shall be implemented for all Selective Houses.
- 1. 1. Groups who are placed in probation for two out of any three years, but whose probation terms are not consecutive, shall be considered consecutive by this standard.
+ 1. i. Houses are expected to make significant strides towards this class breakdown within three years. The RGA committee reserves the right to recommend probation for any house it feels has not made active strides towards this breakdown.
- 1. If a group scores in the top 10% of all houses immediately following a year of probation, their previous year of probation will be forgiven and stricken from the record. Accordingly, this group shall not qualify for house revocation for at least two years.
+ 2. ii. The possibility of a non-selective house assessment process shall also be reviewed at this time.
- Section VI. Group Removal
+ 3. Any amendments must be ratified by the Duke Student Government.
- 1. Groups’ housing privileges may be removed at the end of any academic year.
+ 5. Appendix
- 2. No decision to remove housing privileges may be made without the consultation and deliberation of the ARC.
+ 1. The RGA Scoring Rubric, The precise details of the RGA Scoring Rubric are not provided in this Bylaw of the RGA process. The rubric is appended.
## Sources
- [Duke - ARC (Selective Living) Bylaws.pdf](https://drive.google.com/file/d/10nfw5cvBzisrKn6oc-Qiyl-fGudCYWWk/view?usp=drivesdk)
+ [Duke - RGAC (Residential Assessment) Bylaws.pdf](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EBxj_Ja7km2YI-rtGZD39qB8CSEpSEW8/view?usp=drivesdk)

Amendments between these editions